Who We Are...
Paul I. Sheaffer Insurance Agency, founded in 1951, was established to serve the insurance needs of individuals and families with dedication and trust. Today, the second generation is leading the company through the ever-changing industry. Under the guidance of Paul I. Sheaffer, II, the company has acquired the R. H. Brown Agency in Lancaster and the Horst Insurance Agency in Annville, PA, and has grown to be a full service agency representing over 40 insurance companies, insuring more than 2,400 families and 1,000 businesses in the region.

Our offices have expanded to two locations, each with state-of-the-art computer systems for concise record keeping. Our computer software is designed so that instant rate comparisons can be made of the country’s finest insurance companies.. .the information you need to make those important decisions for your own peace of mind.