Slide background

Pennsylvania's Hometown Friend In The Business



Click or Call: (717) 768-8236

Slide background



Always secure and convenient.

Slide background

A Pennsylvania Tradition of Dedication and Service.



Intercourse, PA | Lancaster, PA.

Slide background

Great protection at your speed and budget.



We keep you moving in the right direction.

Slide background

Protection for Homes, Condos, Property Owners, & Renters



Enjoy insurance from an experienced local independent agent.

Slide background

Your business demands great affordable coverage and support.



We work overtime to insure you're properly insured.

Slide background

Property & Liability Insurance You Can Count On.



Our independence means we work only for you.

Slide background

For businesses small to large.



Because they trust you, you need someone to trust.

Slide background

Individual and family plans.



You'll feel better about your health coverage.


Your personal insurance protects, repairs, and can replace those things in life you’ve worked so hard for when disasters small or large occur.


Your business is important to us all. We want to be your choice for responsive, cost competitive, customized insurance.


We’ve made servicing your needs secure and convenient, anytime from anywhere. Policy changes, requests, certificates and much more.


Our priority is to always serve you first. We’re independent, just like you are. View our contacts, staff, location details and more.

Companies We Represent

“We take pride in ALWAYS being there for our clients. We see every relationship as an opportunity to personally provide value, understanding, education and customized solutions – that exceed expectations.”

Paul I. Sheaffer Insurance Agency

The Paul I. Sheaffer Insurance Agency was established to serve the insurance needs of individuals and families with professionalism, dedication and trust. Under the guidance of Paul I. Sheaffer, II, the agency has grown into a full service agency representing over 40 insurance companies and insuring more than 2,400 families and 1,000 businesses in the Lancaster County region.

We currently have two locations, each with state-of-the-art computer systems for concise and precise record keeping. Our computer software is designed so that instant rate comparisons can be made between the country’s finest insurance companies.. Our mission is to give you the information you need to make those important insurance decisions for your own peace of mind.

As a founding agency in the Insurance Alliance of Central Pennsylvania, we are able to offer access to insuance carriers and programs that unaffiliated insurance agencies have difficulty matching. This is because, as a group, Alliance members control more than $240 million dollars worth of Personal and Commercial insurance premium throughout the Lehigh Valley and surrounding areas of Pennsylvania.

We are Professionally Licensed in the following States: Pennsylvania, Maryland, Delaware, New Jersey


Paul I. Sheaffer Insurance Agency
3541 Old Philadelphia Pike
Intercourse, PA 17534

Office Hours: M-F 8am-4:30pm
Tel: (717) 768-8236
Toll Free: (877) 768-8236
Fax: (717) 768-7575

Fast Quote Request

Finding greater savings with fantastic local service has never been easier.
    Make your selection above then Click GO and you're automatically taken to our secure portal where you'll easily provide your needs and contact information.
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.


As an independent agent, we represent many insurance companies. Our role is to serve as a trusted advisor. We will consult with you to help you understand your needs before recommending the best combination of coverage, service, and value for your unique situation.

We will:

  • Identify the insurance services that are right for you
  • Guide you through the claims process for a quick and fair resolution
  • Counsel you on matters related to your coverage or account
  • Provide prompt service with a unique personal touch

We won’t simply sell you a product—we will be a resource you can count on to look out for your best interests.

  • Always Independent

    Strong proven independent markets.

  • Constantly Supportive

    The pinnacle of personal service and support.

  • Experienced & Knowledgeable

    Experience and trust you can rely on.

  • Service That Matters

    Secure and convenient online services that go anywhere you go.


We Insure Your Way Of Life

We’re in business to provide broad market insurance solutions for both commercial and personal insurance needs. All backed by our dedicated team of local experienced insurance professionals and representing a number of the best insurers available anywhere:

  • Personal Insurance for your autos, home, motorcycles, boats, recreational vehicles, liabilities and so much more.
  • Business Insurance designed around your specific needs and unique risks.
  • Group Benefits designed around your needs to serve your businesses greatest assets and resources.
  • Life and Health Insurance fit for any lifestyle and budget.
  • World-Class Service and Support that’s responsive and friendly every step of the way.

Recent News Posts

Occupational Development Center

We love our volunteers and we love the local business community, and when the two come together, it's a wonderful thing!   This is Devin, who is volunteering with us today to get our sign posts freshly painted to match our brand new sign out front.   Devin works for ...
Read More

Insuring Your College Student

When your child leaves for college, it is a big event. One thing that you should think about is your insurance coverage and how it could change with your son or daughter away at school. Protecting Your Student's Belongings Many homeowners policies consider a dorm room as an extension of ...
Read More

Boat Insurance for Smooth Sailing

You can insure just about any kind of vessel, whether you have a yacht, speed boat or personal watercraft like a JetSki. Every type of boat has the potential to be stolen or damaged, and can be involved in an incident that results in harm to another person or their ...
Read More

DISCLAIMER: This Web site provides only a simplified description of coverages and is not a statement of contract. Coverage may not apply in all states. For complete details of coverages, conditions, limits and losses not covered, be sure to read the policy, including all endorsements, or prospectus, if applicable.


Risk Management Announcement & LoginVIEW MESSAGE