Paul I Sheaffer Insurance Agency, Inc.
Claims

Although claims are the reason people purchase insurance, we understand how upsetting it is to be involved in an accident or to experience damage to your home or belongings .  Our staff is available from 8 until 5 on weekdays to provide personalized service..  You are encouraged to report your claim directly to our office.  We work for you, and we want to ensure that you have your claim processed in a timely manner.

Our staff at Sheaffer is always ready to file your claim on your behalf.  Should you need to file a claim outside of office hours, please use the following claims hotline numbers to contact your carrier directly:

 Cincinnati Insurance    Please call the agency. na
 Chubb 800 252 4670 web link  
 CNA 877 262 2727 web link
 Donegal 800 877 9006 web link
 Eastern Alliance

800 336 3658

web link
 Foremost 800 527 3907 web link
 Goodville Mutual 877 445 5780 web link
 Harleysville Insurance 800 892 8877 web link
 Lititz Mutual 866 420 0264 na
 Middlesex Mutual     Please call the agency. na
 Millers Mutual

800 745 4555

web link
 Pennsylvania National    

800 766 2245 (all other)
800 373 4990 (WC only)

web link
 PMA

888 476 2669 (8 - 5 EST)
800 222 2749 (after 5)

web link
 Progressive 800 925 2886 web link
 Selective Insurance    

866 455 9969 
877 348 0552 (Flood)

web link
 Travelers  (office hours only)

800 252 4633 Persnl
800 238 6225 Comml

web link

Web Hosting Companies