Paul I. Sheaffer Insurance Agency

We are pleased to be Licensed in the following States: Pennsylvania, Maryland, Delaware, New Jersey.

The Paul I. Sheaffer Insurance Agency, founded in 1951, was established to serve the insurance needs of individuals and families with professionalism, dedication and trust. Under the guidance of Paul I. Sheaffer, II, the agency has grown into a full service agency representing over 40 insurance companies and insuring more than 2,400 families and 1,000 businesses in the Lancaster County region. The acquisition of the R. H. Brown Agency in Lancaster and the Horst Insurance Agency in Annville, PA, are in accordance with our agency plan to be the premier independent insurance agency in Central Pennsylvania.

We currently have two locations, each with state-of-the-art computer systems for concise and precise record keeping. Our computer software is designed so that instant rate comparisons can be made between the country’s finest insurance companies.. Our mission is to give you the information you need to make those important insurance decisions for your own peace of mind.

As a founding agency in the Insurance Alliance of Central Pennsylvania, we are able to offer access to insuance carriers and programs that unaffiliated insurance agencies have difficulty matching. This is because, as a group, Alliance members control more than $240 million dollars worth of Personal and Commercial insurance premium throughout the Lehigh Valley and surrounding areas of Pennsylvania.

Our Commitment

True to our location in Intercourse PA-the heart of the Amish Country-we strive to always embody the traditional values of our region by acting in the most ethical manner possible to represent our client’s insurance interests.

You can feel confident in placing your personal or business insurance in our hands.

We invite you to Contact Us concerning your specific insurance needs.