image

Paul I. Sheaffer Insurance Agency
3541 Old Philadelphia Pike
Intercourse, PA 17534

Office Hours: M-F 8am-4:30pm
Tel: (717) 768-8236
Toll Free: (877) 768-8236
Fax: (717) 768-7575
Email: service@nullsheafferins.com

REFER A FRIEND


Mailing Address:
Paul I. Sheaffer Insurance Agency
P.O. Box 449
Intercourse, PA 17534

  • Communicate With Us


    We would love to hear from you! Please complete this simple form and we will get in touch with you soon.


    * - Indicates a required response.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Personnel Directory:

Name, Telephone & EmailTitle
PAUL I. SHEAFFER II
Tel: (717) 768-8236 Ext. 109
psheaffer@nullsheafferins.com
Agency Principal
PAMELA MATTSON, CISR
Tel: (717) 768-8236 Ext. 108
pmattson@nullsheafferins.com
Account Executives
KIM GRAY
Tel: (717) 768-8236 Ext. 114
kgray@nullsheafferins.com
Commercial Lines Insurance Advisors
CAITLIN BLUM
Tel: (717) 768-8236 Ext. 116
cblum@nullsheafferins.com
Commercial Lines Insurance Advisors
MICHAEL GREINER
Tel: (717) 768-8236 Ext. 122
mgreiner@nullsheafferins.com
Commercial Lines Insurance Advisors
DON MYERS
Tel: (717) 768-8236 Ext. 113
dmyers@nullsheafferins.com
Commercial Lines Insurance Advisors
MACK DELVECCHIO
Tel: (717) 768-8236 Ext. 105
mdelvecchio@nullsheafferins.com
Commercial Lines Insurance Advisors
NANCY GARZIA, CIC, CISR
Tel: (717) 768-8236 Ext. 120
ngarzia@nullsheafferins.com
Accounting
Personal Lines Insurance Advisors
AMY HUYETT
Tel: (717) 768-8236 Ext. 103
ahuyett@nullsheafferins.com
Personal Lines Insurance Advisors
DENNIS ZIMMERMAN
Tel: (717) 768-8236 Ext. 112
dzimmerman@nullsheafferins.com
Employee Benefits Account Manager and Personal Lines Advisor
DANIEL STOLTZFUS
Tel: (717) 768-8236 Ext. 124
dstoltzfus@nullsheafferins.com
Safety Director
CHRISTOPHER ESH
Tel: (717) 768-8236 Ext. 115
cesh@nullsheafferins.com
Claims Administration