Insurance Companies, Claims & Bill Payments

At Paul I. Sheaffer Insurance Agency we are pleased to represent the full array of insurance products and services from the following highly-rated companies.

Available within these listings you are likely to see direct links to each carrier’s primary website, online bill payment integration, claim submissions and company-direct telephone information for additional policy service and support.




Acuity

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

800-242-7666

Americsafe

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

800-699-6240

AmWINS Group

Company:

Website

Berkley Mid-Atlantic Group

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

N/A

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

877-262-4178

Brethren Mutual

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

800-621-4264

Brickstreet Insurance

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

866-452-7425

Chubb

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

800-252-4670

Cincinnati Insurance Companies

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

877-242-2544

Glass Claims:

877-588-4527

CNA

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

877-574-0540
View Details

Donegal Insurance Group

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

800-877-9006

Eastern Alliance

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

888-654-7100

Fireman’s Fund Insurance Company

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

888-347-3428

FirstComp

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

888-500-3344

Foremost Insurance Group

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

Auto:
800-274-7865
Property:
800-527-3907

Grange Insurance

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

800-445-3030

Grinnell Mutual Reinsurance Company

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

877-467-2252

Guard Insurance Group

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

888-639-2567

Goodville Mutual

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

717-354-4921

Harleysville

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

800-892-8877

The Hartford

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

Auto: 800-243-5860
Auto AARP Members: 877-805-9918
Home: 800-243-5860
Home AARP Members: 877-805-9918
Commercial: 800-327-3636

Lackawanna Insurance Group

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

Click Here

Liberty Mutual

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

800-225-2467

Lititz Mutual Insurance Company

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Claims/Service:

800-626-4751

   

MiddleOak

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

800-225-2533

Millers Mutual Group


 

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

800-745-4555

The Motorist Insurance Group

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

800-876-6642

Mutual Benefit Group

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

800-290-6361

Nationwide

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

800-421-3535

Ohio Casualty

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

866-255-5530

Peerless Insurance

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

800-522-7152

Penn National Insurance

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

800-766-2245

Pennsylvania Lumbermens

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

N/A

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

800-752-1895

PMA Insurance Group

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

N/A

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

888.476.2669

Progressive Insurance

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

800-776-4737

Safeco Insurance

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

800-332-3226

Selective Insurance

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

866-455-9969

State Auto Insurance Companies

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

877-722-5246

Travelers

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

Personal: 800-252-4633
Commercial: 800-238-6225

Tuscarora Wayne Insurance Company

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

Contact Your Agent or Call 570-746-1515

The United Fire Group

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

800-343-9131

Westfield Insurance

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

800-243-0210

The Zenith

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service:

800-440-5020

Zurich Insurance Services

Company:

Website

Bill Pay:

Payments

Online Claims:

Claims

Claims/Service: 800-987-3373